Intruder - Peter Gabriel
When I was in HS, this song was creey enough on its own. Then weird things happened while listening to it. I was driving down the highway in my van and all the lights for the van went out. At around midnight. When Craig was listening to the song (approximately) the house next door to him was robbed. When wizardru was listening to it, his house was struck by lightning. Co-incidence? Of course. Creepy? Of course.